McCormick veya Smucker: Bir Temettü Aristokrat Diğerini Aşacak

McCormick or Smucker: One Dividend Aristocrat Will Outrun the Other

Chris Lange

Thu, September 17, 2026 at 3:11 PM GMT+3 5 min read

• SJM +1.53%
• MKC +0.40%

Quick Read

• McCormick (MKC) delivers 40 consecutive dividend increases and a forward P/E of 15 post-selloff; Smucker (SJM) offers cheaper value but fragile earnings.

• Smucker generates $975 million in free cash flow covering its dividend comfortably, but goodwill impairments and coffee tariffs erode earnings quality.

• McCormick's flavor brands deliver 40% gross margins and 30% operating income growth, structural advantages Smucker's coffee and snack portfolio cannot match.

• Just released. Our analysts combed the entire stock market and named the ten best stocks to buy right now, and McCormick didn't make the cut. Enter your email to see the names that beat MKC. The report is free. Enter your email and see if any of your stocks made the cut.

For a retirement-focused investor weighing two consumer staples dividend payers, the choice between McCormick (NYSE:MKC) and J.M. Smucker (NYSE:SJM) carries more nuance than a yield screen suggests. Both trade with roughly the same market cap and roughly the same dividend yield, yet they have moved in opposite directions this year: MKC is down 24.68% year to date while SJM is up 29.27%. Which one belongs in a retirement account right now?

Round One: Income Stream and Increase Record

The headline yields are nearly identical. MKC pays a 3.69% yield on a $0.48 quarterly dividend, and SJM pays 3.64% on a $1.12 quarterly payout. The difference shows up in the track record. McCormick's board authorized a 7% increase in November 2025, marking the 40th consecutive year of dividend increases, and the dividend record confirms the step from $0.45 to $0.48 beginning with the December 29, 2025 ex-dividend date. Smucker's record shows steady but slower raises: $1.10 to $1.12 on the August 14, 2026 ex-date, following a jump from $1.08 to $1.10 the prior year.

Free Report, Just Released

Why Didn't MKC Make The Top 10 List?

24/7 Wall St has helped investors make money for over two decades, and our top analysts just finished ranking the definitive Top 10 Stocks To Buy Now. Not the ten biggest companies. Not the ten everyone is arguing about. The ten best stocks to buy right now.

And MKC didn't make the cut!

The report is free, and you can see why we think each stock is a top investment today.

Enter Your Email and See the Ten →

Round Two: Cash Flow Coverage and Balance Sheet

This is where SJM punches back. Smucker generated operating cash flow of $1.4736 billion in fiscal 2026 against dividend payments of $464.7 million, and management raised full-year free cash flow guidance to $975 million, describing the benefit as ongoing rather than one-time. Coverage is comfortable even after two years of impairment-driven GAAP losses, including a $961.7 million goodwill and intangible impairment on Sweet Baked Snacks and Hostess. McCormick covers its dividend as well, with FY2025 dividends of $483 million against operating cash flow of $962.2 million, but its balance sheet is about to absorb the proposed Unilever Foods combination creating a roughly $20 billion revenue company. Both carriers are levered post-acquisition; SJM currently converts more cash per dollar of dividend. Edge: SJM.

Round Three: Business Quality and Pricing Power

The business models are genuinely different. McCormick owns the flavor aisle through McCormick, French's, Frank's RedHot, Cholula, OLD BAY, and Lawry's, with a Q2 FY26 gross margin that expanded 270 basis points to 40.2% and adjusted operating income up 30% year over year. Smucker's portfolio of Folgers, Dunkin', Jif, Uncrustables, Hostess, and Milk-Bone is contending with commodity coffee tariffs, a net 50 cents negative tariff impact embedded in guidance, and a Sweet Baked Snacks segment that fell 7% in Q1 FY27 after a 19% decline in Q3 FY26. Flavor is a structurally higher-margin category than jam, coffee, and snack cakes. MKC wins on business quality, decisively.

Verdict

For the classic retirement portfolio, the winner is McCormick. A 40-year increase streak, a category with real pricing power, a beta of 0.634, and a stock that has been marked down to a forward P/E of 15 after a 24% year-to-date drawdown is exactly the setup retirees want: a wounded compounder with a growing income stream. SJM's trailing P/E of 57 reflects impairment-scarred earnings, and while forward P/E of 12 looks cheap, the Hostess overhang, coffee tariff exposure, and reliance on non-repeatable tariff refunds make the earnings base fragile.

SJM has a place for a yield-focused investor who wants deeper value and can stomach the Hostess turnaround; the FCF coverage is genuinely strong. But for a retiree who needs a dividend that will still be growing in 2036, McCormick is the pick. The market has handed long-term income investors a rare discount on a Dividend Aristocrat, and taking it is the straightforward call.

Got $1,000? Before You Buy MKC, Read This

If you have cash sitting in your account right now, give this two minutes. After more than two decades of helping investors beat the market, our top analysts at 24/7 Wall St. put together a definitive report on the Top 10 Stocks To Buy Today. And MKC wasn't one of them.

They combed the entire market. It's not 10 ideas, not 10 stocks everyone is talking about, it's what their research points to as the 10 best stocks to buy right now, and it's free. Read more here and see which stocks made the list -->>

Contact editorial@247wallst.com for any questions or corrections.